Why Does a Whirly Tube Jump Between Musical Notes?

By

·

A whirly tube can jump between notes as it swings faster. Its ridges help turn moving air into organized sound.

A long yellow corrugated musical tube with a widened end.
A whirly tube, not the measured instrument. Image: chridd, CC BY 4.0; unmodified.

Airflow feeds a resonance

A 2012 investigation by Güneş Nakiboğlu and colleagues examined the toy with experiments and models. Swinging drives air through the tube. At the internal corrugations, flow separates and develops unstable layers that roll into vortices. Those disturbances interact with the tube’s standing sound waves.

This is feedback, not simply air rubbing noisily against plastic. The flow supplies energy while the resonant air column helps select a tone. The team’s model predicted characteristic whistling frequencies well, but was less successful at predicting loudness. Tube geometry and the distribution of flow speed both mattered.

Pitch climbs in steps

In 2011 experiments led by Maria Eva Amorim, researchers pumped air through a corrugated sound tube instead of swinging it. A microphone, oscilloscope and air-speed meter let them compare the sound with the flow. Increasing airflow produced a staircase of frequencies rather than a continuous slide.

The observed steps corresponded to standing-wave harmonics. The lowest detected step was the second harmonic; the fundamental was inferred from the spacing, not directly heard in that experiment. The result distinguishes a tube’s possible resonances from the particular modes that its airflow can actually sustain.

Red corrugated conduits projecting from pavement beside a utility box.
Corrugated conduits illustrate the ridged form, not tested musical tubes. Photo: Lagoset, CC BY-SA 4.0; resized.

Ridges can serve other purposes: compare a bendy straw’s stable folds.

Responses

  1. […] Compare another route to stepped pitch: the whirly tube’s airflow-driven notes. […]

  2. […] Compare airflow-driven whirly-tube notes. […]

Add comment

Leave a Reply