A floating stone seems contradictory. Pumice resolves the puzzle with pores, but those spaces do not all behave alike when water arrives.
Closed spaces can matter
A 2024 study examined pumice from Japan’s 2021 Fukutoku-Oka-no-Ba eruption. Density measurements indicated that most floating samples contained enough isolated pores to remain buoyant even if their connected pores filled with seawater. These sealed spaces are different from passages open to the outside. The authors called such pumice “unsinkable” under that saturation criterion, not indestructible forever. Simply seeing a stone afloat cannot establish which kind it is.
Other stones gradually fill
In a 2025 experiment, five pumice samples from Sakurajima’s 1914 eruption behaved differently. Water entered rapidly at first, then more slowly. Later uptake particularly involved regions classified as dead-end pores, including water along walls and corners. Original stones floated from minutes to beyond the experiment’s ten-day cutoff. Pore architecture mattered; this small sample did not establish a universal sinking timetable. Trapped air in connected spaces is not equivalent to a permanently sealed pore.

Compare the closed compartments in cork’s cellular structure.

Leave a Reply