How Can Losing Ice Create Fields of Pointed Penitentes?

By

·

Penitentes are fields of pointed snow or ice. Their striking relief can develop while the illuminated surface is losing material.

A field of tall white penitentes above bare ground at Agua Negra.
Natural penitentes at Agua Negra. Vrac / CC BY-SA 4.0; resized.

Uneven removal creates relief

In 2006 laboratory experiments, illuminated snow developed centimeter-scale penitentes. Reflections concentrate radiation in depressions, favoring faster removal there. Sublimation, the direct conversion of ice into vapor, was important during initiation and increasing spacing between peaks.

Once structures existed, melting could continue increasing their height relative to the troughs without further widening their spacing. This was laboratory evidence about small formations, not a complete reproduction of a mountain snowfield.

Pressure changes the outcome

A 2024 experiment illuminated ice inside a cooled, partly evacuated chamber. Millimeter-scale structures appeared near the equilibrium water-vapor pressure for the ice’s temperature. Added nitrogen suppressed their formation in a comparison between otherwise similar tests.

The illuminated area lost material overall, but fine ridges suggested possible local redeposition at tips. The authors explicitly left that possibility unresolved. Small laboratory spikes therefore illuminate competing processes without proving that every natural penitente follows precisely the same history.

Pointed white snow formations on a rocky mountainside near Aconcagua.
Penitentes near Aconcagua, not laboratory specimens. Sastognuti / CC BY-SA 4.0; resized.

Contrast hair ice on wood: a pointed icy appearance does not identify one universal formation mechanism.

Response

  1. […] pointed penitentes, a different pattern associated with uneven ice […]

Add comment

Leave a Reply