Why Don’t Dark Glacier Bands Always Melt Faster?

By

·

Some glaciers carry curved light and dark bands called band ogives. Their appearance alone does not reveal how quickly each band melts.

Curved alternating bands crossing the Mer de Glace amid mountain shadows.
Mer de Glace, 2012. © Günter Seggebäing, CC BY-SA 3.0; resized.

Bands are more than surface dirt

A 2002 field study examined Bas Glacier d’Arolla in Switzerland. Dark bands contained more closely spaced layers of blue, bubble-poor ice, a structure called foliation. Rain could wash away superficial debris without erasing the contrasting bands. Weathering also created small ridges that trapped dirt. Structural mapping and radar supported a proposed shearing mechanism that could bring deeper ice upward, but the authors called for further measurements rather than presenting a settled explanation for every glacier.

Different brightness, similar ice loss

At Mer de Glace, a 2018 study compared annual measurements across dark and light bands from 2004 to 2015. Both lost similar amounts of surface mass, despite the darker ice reflecting less sunlight. The lighter bands were rougher. Modeling suggested stronger turbulent heat exchange there could offset the darker bands’ greater solar absorption. Wind estimates, roughness calculations and simplified airflow introduced uncertainty. The result challenges explanations requiring strongly unequal melting, without supplying a complete theory of band formation.

Oblique view of repeated curved bands across pale glacier ice beneath a rocky slope.
Mer de Glace, 2014; not a melt measurement. Lionel Duchoiselle, CC BY-SA 3.0; resized.

Compare pointed penitentes, a different pattern associated with uneven ice removal.

Add comment

Leave a Reply