Why Do Some Sand Dunes Boom?

By

·

Some desert dunes produce sustained musical booms when sand avalanches. Explaining the sound requires distinguishing what moving grains generate from how vibrations travel.

Curved crests and steep sand slopes within Eureka Dunes, with mountains beyond.
Eureka Dunes landscape, not an acoustic recording. Photo: G. Thomas; author-released public domain, displayed smaller.

Singing in a laboratory

A 2012 study compared field recordings with sand avalanching in a shallow, hard-bottomed laboratory channel. Sand collected in Oman produced several frequencies; sieving it into a narrower grain-size range produced a clearer tone. The authors argued that synchronized motion within flowing grains could generate singing without a deep dune underneath.

That result challenged explanations requiring the entire dune to act as a resonator. It did not establish that every audible sand sound has an identical mechanism.

Booms versus short bursts

A 2015 field investigation at Eureka and Dumont dunes measured vibrations using arrays of ground-motion sensors. The researchers distinguished brief, broad-frequency “burps” from sustained booming. Their measurements associated dominant burping vibrations with surface waves, but dominant booming with faster compressional waves traveling through the dune.

They interpreted sustained booming as a larger-scale process involving trapped waves, and questioned whether small laboratory sounds reproduce it. These studies therefore disagree about which observations belong to the same phenomenon, not simply whether sand can make noise.

Pale Dumont dune slopes rise above a desert foreground beneath distant mountains.
Dumont Dunes, another field-study location; this photograph does not demonstrate sound. Photo: Stan Shebs, CC BY-SA 3.0; displayed smaller.

For visible grain movement, compare sand ripples.

Add comment

Leave a Reply