What Did Two Experiments Reveal About Rotating Ice Disks?

By

·

A spinning ice disk is not automatically a self-powered wheel. Laboratory studies separate melting-driven flows from movements already present in the surrounding water.

A long exposure turns a moving ice disk into sweeping pale arcs beside a snowy bank.
Long exposure at Esopus Creek, not an experiment. Juliancolton; CC0; resized.

Melting can move water

In 2016 experiments, small ice disks rotated in a temperature-controlled bath. Particle tracking revealed descending water and horizontal swirling beneath them. The researchers proposed that cooling water toward its maximum density near 4°C created a sinking plume, whose associated swirl dragged the ice around. Warmer baths produced faster average rotation. This laboratory result did not establish that melting alone drives every large river disk; river currents offer another source of motion.

A closer look at the trigger

A 2023 investigation allowed water to settle before gently releasing disks. Some turned either way; others stayed nearly still. A chilled, non-melting plastic control also rotated slowly, while a room-temperature control remained still. The authors suggested that cooling-driven convection could amplify residual water movements. Their images showed a contracting plume, but not the earlier proposed vortex. Crucially, their discussion left the precise trigger unresolved: measuring average background speed did not reveal every local twisting force.

A snow-covered circular ice floe lies within a narrow open-water ring at Vana-Vigala.
Vana-Vigala ice disk. Luc Saffre / Till.niermann; CC BY-SA 4.0; contrast-enhanced derivative, resized.

Compare another hidden flow: tea leaves gathering inside a stirred cup.

Add comment

Leave a Reply