Why Does Hair Ice Grow on Dead Wood?

By

·

On a damp winter walk, a dead branch can appear to have grown a silky white mane. The strands are ice, not fur or fungal threads. Its familiar name describes an unfamiliar sight.

Close view of fine white hair-ice strands beside brown fallen leaves.
Fine strands give hair ice its silky appearance. Photo: TOMMES-WIKI, CC BY-SA 3.0; resized.

A narrow window of weather

The Met Office’s frost and ice guide describes the ingredients: moist, rotting broadleaf wood, moist air, and temperatures slightly below freezing. This is not a decoration that appears on every cold stick. The substrate and weather must coincide.

For an observer, that suggests looking closely at fallen wood rather than only at frozen puddles or grass. Record where the strands emerge and photograph the whole branch as well as a close view. Those contextual details are more informative than a tightly cropped image of something white. Leave the wood where it is; the observation does not require breaking it open.

Freezing makes the ice; a fungus helps shape it

In a 2015 study researchers found the fungus Exidiopsis effusa on every investigated hair-ice sample. Treatments that suppressed fungal activity also suppressed hair-ice production.

Wood with active fungi and wood with fungi killed showed similar temperature changes and freezing rates. The shared mechanism was ice segregation: liquid water is drawn through wood toward the freezing surface. Their conclusion assigned the fungus a different role: helping produce fine hairs and preventing them from merging into larger crystals through recrystallization.

The strands are ice, not frost-coated fungal tissue.

White hair ice curling from a short piece of wood above a leaf-covered forest floor.
A wider view shows hair ice on wood among fallen leaves. Photo: Youbadou, CC BY-SA 4.0; resized.

The chemical explanation is still being refined

A 2023 conference abstract by Hofmann and colleagues reported high-resolution mass-spectrometry work on melted hair ice. The samples contained complex mixtures, with lignin- and tannin-related material prominent in the authors’ interpretation. They proposed roles for these substances in freezing and in inhibiting recrystallization.

This conference report proposes a chemical explanation, not proof of one universal “hair-ice ingredient.”

Hair ice is not every kind of needle-shaped ice

In a 2024 field account an observer initially wondered about ice strands on a forest floor, then identified them as needle ice. Needle ice grows from soil as water moves upward and freezes. Its columns can look strikingly similar at first glance, but the substrate and structure are different.

Start with the question “What is it growing from?” rather than naming the formation from its silhouette alone. Our explanation of spikes on ice cubes offers another reminder: water can build unusual shapes through several distinct mechanisms. A shared icy appearance is not evidence of a shared biological cause.

Response

  1. […] hair ice on wood: a pointed icy appearance does not identify one universal formation […]

Add comment

Leave a Reply