Why Does Blue Cheese Have Blue Veins? Air, Fungi and Flavor

By

·

The blue-green patches in blue cheese are not dye stirred through the curd. They are the visible work of a fungus, Penicillium roqueforti. Yet the uneven pattern raises a useful question: why does the color collect in channels and pockets instead of appearing uniformly throughout the cheese?

Roquefort wedge with blue-green pockets beside its labeled wrapping.
Roquefort shows irregular blue-green pockets through the cut cheese. Photo: Dominik Hundhammer, CC BY-SA 3.0. Resized; no crop.

Air helps reveal the fungus

P. roqueforti needs oxygen to produce the spores responsible for the blue-green appearance. Air-containing cavities therefore provide places where that visible color develops. A cheese can contain fungal growth without every part becoming equally blue. Cheesemakers can provide air routes deliberately: Colston Bassett Dairy describes piercing its cheeses to admit oxygen and begin the blueing process.

A 2020 study by Emilie Dumas and colleagues examined genetically differentiated populations of this fungus. Among the differences they investigated was the ability to colonize cheese cavities. Their results help explain why the identity of the fungal strain matters alongside the physical spaces available inside the cheese.

The fungus changes flavor, not just color

Thibault Caron and colleagues tested that connection directly in a 2021 cheesemaking experiment. They used three strains from each of four fungal populations, inoculating each experimental cheese with a single strain and following Roquefort-type production specifications.

Cheeses made with strains from cheese-associated populations developed more blue area and more of the volatile compounds typical of blue cheese than those made with strains from the other populations. These compounds included methyl ketones and secondary alcohols, molecules that contribute to aroma.

The Roquefort strains produced especially high amounts of those aromatic compounds, partly associated with more effective breakdown of proteins and fats. The experiment was not a ranking of supermarket cheeses or a claim that stronger blue color always means better flavor. It showed that fungal ancestry can change the outcome even within a controlled cheesemaking approach.

A wedge of Blue Stilton with blue veins and crumbled pieces on a dark plate.
Blue Stilton, shown for comparison rather than as an experimental sample. Photo: Jon Sullivan, public domain. Resized; no crop.

One fungal species contains different histories

Those four populations were not the end of the story. Ewen Crequer and colleagues reported another population in 2023, associated with traditional French Termignon cheeses. These cheeses undergo spontaneous blue-mold colonization, rather than following the same inoculation route as the controlled experiment above.

The Termignon population was genetically distinct from the four previously identified groups and contained substantial genetic diversity. This finding makes “the blue-cheese mold” a useful common label, but not a description of one interchangeable strain with one history.

Deliberate cheesemaking is not accidental spoilage

None of this makes unexpected mold on food safe. USDA’s mold guidance distinguishes molds used in cheese production from unwanted growth. Follow the product’s storage instructions and food-safety guidance; do not identify an unknown mold as safe just because it looks blue.

Cheese can also offer a completely different sensory puzzle: why fresh curds squeak. That is a question about physical texture and sound, rather than blue-cheese ripening.

Add comment

Leave a Reply