Why Does a Whip Make a Crack?

By

·

A whip can make a sharp crack without striking a surface. The sound comes from a tiny, fast-moving region near its end, not from the entire length moving at one enormous speed.

A brown Australian bullwhip coiled on a pale surface, with its fine end inside the coil.
An Australian bullwhip at rest, not a recording of a crack. Photo: Cgoodwin, CC BY-SA 3.0; resized only.

Catching a very brief event

In a 1998 high-speed imaging experiment, P. Krehl, S. Engemann and D. Schwenkel coordinated a camera, an acoustic trigger and pulsed laser illumination. Shadowgraph images let them connect the motion of the end tuft with the shock wave it produced.

Their reported tuft speed reached Mach 2.19: more than twice the local speed of sound. Supersonic motion lasted about 1.2 milliseconds. These are measurements from that experiment, not guaranteed values for every whip. The shock appeared as the cracker rapidly turned around at the lash’s turning point.

A dark braided bullwhip with a wooden handle hangs coiled against pegboard.
A different bullwhip with a relatively long handle and short lash; neither photograph shows the experimental apparatus. Photo: Montanabw, CC BY-SA 3.0; resized only.

A traveling bend, then an accelerating end

Tyler McMillen and Alain Goriely’s 2003 mathematical study treated the whip as an elastic rod carrying a loop. Tapering accelerated the traveling loop. The rapid unfolding at the free end required separate numerical calculations.

The model allowed bending but assumed no stretching or shearing, motion in one plane, and no air friction in its mechanical calculation. It isolates mechanisms rather than reproducing every detail.

The calculated shock shapes agreed with photographed shocks, supporting an origin at the tip or a small nearby section. A traveling loop is not a single material point. Compare another flexible object: the changing shape of a Slinky.

Response

  1. […] Motion and sound need separate measurements. For another example, compare research on a whip’s crack. […]

Add comment

Leave a Reply