Why Does a Magnet Fall Slowly Through a Copper Tube?

By

·

A magnet can fall surprisingly slowly through a copper tube, even though copper does not hold it like a steel refrigerator door. The slowing comes from electric currents created by the magnet’s motion. Their magnetic fields act back on the falling magnet, opposing its descent.

Short copper pipe section viewed from the side.
A copper pipe section, shown as a material example rather than a recorded falling-magnet experiment. Photo: MdeVicente, CC0 1.0; original image retained.

A useful comparison removes the mystery

Simon Fraser University’s classroom demonstration compares a copper tube with a glass tube. An ordinary aluminum cylinder passes through both. A magnet passes through the glass readily but descends slowly through the copper. Comparing objects of the same diameter helps rule out a hidden obstruction.

The important difference is the conducting tube’s electrical response. As the magnet moves, the magnetic field through successive regions of copper changes. Circulating electric currents, called eddy currents, generate magnetic fields that resist the motion. The pipe does not need a battery connected to it.

That makes the effect different from simply sticking to steel. Our refrigerator-magnet explanation covers that more familiar attraction.

Slow falling is not levitation

In Michael Ruiz’s 2006 classroom report, a magnet took about 3.3 seconds to traverse a roughly 25-centimeter aluminum tube. For comparison, free fall over that distance takes only about a quarter of a second. The result also shows that copper is not the only conducting material that can produce the effect.

The magnet continued moving rather than hovering. Over most of its passage, its speed was approximately steady. This is terminal speed: the upward braking force balances its weight, so its downward speed stops increasing.

The feedback explains the balance. Faster motion produces a faster change in magnetic flux, which can produce a stronger resisting force in this regime. Slower motion weakens that effect. The reported travel time belongs to that apparatus, not to every magnet or every metal tube.

Close view of a metal disc passing through the gap of a magnetic braking assembly in an electricity meter.
A different geometry: an eddy-current brake beside an aluminum disc in a 1973 electricity meter. Photo: Olli Niemitalo, CC0 1.0; resized.

Where the lost energy goes

The slowing does not destroy energy. Current flowing through resistive metal produces heat. In a 2012 research preprint, Irvine and colleagues calculated the induced currents and braking force for a cylindrical magnet in a copper pipe, comparing their predictions with measurements.

Their apparatus used hanging masses and pulleys to pull the magnet through the pipe at different steady speeds. Within the studied regime, the resisting force increased in proportion to speed. The model linked mechanical power lost to electrical heating in the pipe. This was a quantified comparison, not just a visual impression that the magnet fell slowly.

A useful way to follow a recorded demonstration is to separate three things: the magnet’s motion, the induced current and the opposing force. They form a connected process. Use a prepared classroom recording rather than dismantling electrical equipment or improvising with powerful magnets to reproduce the photographs.

Response

  1. […] The sealed thermal cycle differs from a copper tube braking a falling magnet. […]

Add comment

Leave a Reply