Why Do Ice Cubes Sometimes Grow Spikes? The Upward Ice Mystery

By

·

Open an ice tray and you expect flat-topped cubes, perhaps with a cloudy center. Occasionally, one has a narrow tower sticking out of it. The surprising part is the direction: this little icicle seems to have grown upward.

An ice spike can form when freezing water is pushed through a small opening in an icy surface. It is a growth process, not evidence that something dripped onto the cube from the freezer ceiling.

Freezing water needs more room

The starting point is an unusual property of water. As the International Association for the Properties of Water and Steam explains, ordinary water expands by about nine percent when it freezes. Hydrogen bonds organize its molecules into a relatively open crystal structure, so the solid occupies more space than the liquid did.

The molecules have not grown larger. Their arrangement has changed. This also explains why ordinary ice is less dense than liquid water and can float. In a partly frozen tray compartment, expansion helps displace the liquid that remains.

A narrow transparent ice spike rising from one compartment in a white ice cube tray.
An ice spike photographed in a home freezer. Photo: Evanh2008 at English Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0. Unmodified.

A tiny opening becomes a growing tube

In Caltech physicist Kenneth Libbrecht’s explanation, ice forms over the surface while a small opening remains. Continued freezing below pushes liquid through that opening. Water freezes around the edge of the emerging droplet, extending a thin-walled tube.

More liquid can travel up the middle while the rim keeps freezing. The result is a slender spike rather than a broad mound. Growth ends when the liquid supply is exhausted or its passage freezes closed. The spike is therefore built at its growing end; it is not a finished needle being lifted bodily out of the cube.

Why most cubes do not grow towers

Several processes must stay in balance. Liquid needs a route outward, but the route cannot freeze shut too soon. The edge must freeze quickly enough to build the wall without simply allowing water to spill over.

Experiments by Hill, Lozowski, and Sampson, published in the Journal of Glaciology, support gradual growth over minutes rather than an explosive jet instantly freezing in midair. Their observations also show that the orientation of the ice crystals matters. Small differences at the start can lead to noticeably different shapes.

Numerous upright and tilted ice spikes across frozen water in blue containers.
Multiple ice spikes on frozen water containers, showing a variety of heights and angles. Photo: Priesemut24, CC BY-SA 4.0. Unmodified.

Does the water make a difference?

Yes. Libbrecht’s experiments found that distilled water often produced spikes more readily than tap water, and adding small amounts of salt could suppress them. Air temperature and air movement also affected the results. This is a probability, not a promise: distilled water does not guarantee a tray full of spikes.

Researchers have also noted unanswered questions about details such as the initial diameter and growth angle. A tidy explanation of the main mechanism does not mean every individual spike can be predicted.

A simple observation, not a freezer adjustment

If you find one, photograph it before emptying the tray. Include a side view and an ordinary cube for comparison. Note the water used and whether neighboring compartments formed bumps, flat surfaces, or other spikes. A few batches make a more useful comparison than one unusual cube.

Keep normal freezer settings and leave vents unobstructed. There is no need to change food-storage conditions for an ice experiment.

The freezer hosts more than one slow transformation. Our guide to why ice cubes shrink in the freezer explains a different process, sublimation. A spike records how liquid became ice; a shrinking cube records how ice can later leave as vapor.

Response

  1. […] it growing from?” rather than naming the formation from its silhouette alone. Our explanation of spikes on ice cubes offers another reminder: water can build unusual shapes through several distinct mechanisms. A […]

Add comment

Leave a Reply