Why Can Chickpea Cooking Water Whip Into Foam? Aquafaba Explained

By

·

The liquid drained from cooked chickpeas can turn into a surprisingly persistent foam. Called aquafaba, it is not merely water with a bean flavor. It carries dissolved and dispersed material from the chickpeas, and that mixture can help hold air in place.

White bean cooking liquid being whipped into a pale foam in a jug.
Whipped white-bean aquafaba, not the chickpea samples discussed in the research. Photo: Mangostaniko, CC0; resized.

Air needs a supporting structure

Whipping introduces air bubbles. Proteins can gather at the boundary between air and water and help stabilize that boundary. The surrounding liquid matters too: increasing its viscosity can slow drainage from the films between bubbles. Making bubbles and keeping them intact are related, but they are not the same job.

A 2023 study by Crawford, Tyl and Kerr examined this distinction using chickpea aquafaba prepared by boiling or pressure-cooking. In their sugar-containing model foams, added xanthan gum strongly reduced liquid drainage over 24 hours. Another thickener, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose, behaved differently. The result illustrates why foam performance depends on the complete formulation, not just vigorous beating.

One can is not every can

In a 2018 composition study, Shim and colleagues examined aquafaba from ten commercial canned chickpea products. Their foams differed in volume and stability, and their chemical compositions also varied. Protein-separation methods identified largely heat-soluble, water-attracting proteins; analysis of the foam also detected carbohydrate components.

This is a mixture, not a purified replacement protein. A result from one product cannot automatically predict another product’s behavior. “It whipped up” and “it stayed whipped” are separate observations worth keeping separate when comparing batches.

Rows of small white piped aquafaba meringues on a lined tray.
Chickpea-aquafaba meringues, an illustrative preparation rather than a research sample. Photo: Hagar Or Ringel Maman, CC BY-SA 3.0; existing Commons crop retained, no further changes.

An egg-white substitute, not an identical material

Buhl, Christensen and Hammershøj compared aquafaba with egg white in 2019. Their hand-shaken foams differed in capacity, volume and liquid proportion over time, although their test of liquid drainage found no difference between the two sources. Changing acidity affected most measured properties, but not foam capacity in that particular experiment.

That qualification matters. A liquid can perform similarly on one measure and differently on another. It is therefore more useful to ask whether a particular formulation works in a particular food than to declare aquafaba universally equivalent to egg white. These laboratory comparisons do not establish a single substitution ratio for every recipe.

Keep the science separate from a recipe

For the cooking stage, our guide to preparing dried chickpeas covers tenderness and safe storage, including the cooking liquid. This explanation is not a tested meringue recipe. Follow a recipe developed for aquafaba rather than assuming every egg-white method transfers unchanged.

Response

  1. […] species and experiments answer different questions. Even kitchen foams such as aquafaba show why making bubbles and maintaining useful properties are separate […]

Add comment

Leave a Reply