What Do First and Second Crack Reveal About Roasting Coffee?

By

·

Roasting coffee has a soundtrack. Beans produce distinct cracking sounds as their structure changes, and the pattern can shift as roasting continues. Researchers have investigated whether those noises could become measurements, rather than relying only on a roaster recognizing them by ear.

Large black coffee-roasting machine with a hopper and circular cooling tray in a workspace.
A coffee roaster, not the experimental apparatus discussed here. Photo: Atktiran, CC BY-SA 4.0; resized.

First crack and second crack sound different

Preston S. Wilson’s 2014 acoustic study recorded and analyzed roasting sounds. In those recordings, first-crack events had greater acoustic amplitude and more low-frequency energy than the later second-crack events. The second-crack chorus contained events at a higher rate.

These are three different measurements: how strong a sound is, how its energy is distributed across frequencies, and how frequently events occur. A faster crackling pattern need not mean each individual crack is louder. That distinction is why listening can reveal more than simply whether the beans are making noise.

A changing solid, not just trapped steam

The mechanics behind a crack are more complicated than a miniature pressure vessel bursting. A mathematical study by Nabil Fadai and colleagues examined how temperature, moisture and gas pressure interact with the bean’s changing material properties.

Their model produced a relatively soft, moist interior confined by a drier, more rigid exterior. When those regions changed their mechanical behavior at different times, stresses could rise sharply. The authors proposed this as a route toward the large deformations associated with first crack.

That is a model-based explanation, not a direct film of every cell breaking. It treated a single bean with simplified spherical geometry, and the authors identified uncertain material properties and fracture details requiring further work. The useful lesson is that pressure and the resistance of the surrounding solid must be considered together.

Roasted coffee beans pouring from a roasting chamber into a circular cooling tray.
Beans leaving a roaster for its cooling tray; this photograph does not identify a particular crack stage. Photo: Jkafader, CC BY-SA 3.0; resized.

What microphones can and cannot tell us

In a 2024 experiment, Hubertus Siebald and colleagues recorded five roasting methods with different starting temperatures, repeating each five times. They explored acoustic changes and an estimate of the proportion of beans that had cracked.

Counting is not straightforward: several beans may crack simultaneously, and their distance from a microphone changes the recorded level. The researchers used averaged and normalized signals to address those difficulties. They also called for tests of reproducibility and transfer to other roasters, batches and varieties.

Crucially, the study did not investigate the relationship between sound and aroma development. A microphone can provide process information without independently proving that the coffee will taste good. For another visible clue with its own limits, see why roasted beans can look oily.

Add comment

Leave a Reply