Churning changes how cream’s fat and water are arranged. Butter is not simply cream made thicker by stirring.

Which material surrounds which?
In cream, fat globules are dispersed through a watery continuous phase. Churning reverses that arrangement: small water droplets become dispersed within a continuous fat phase. This change is called phase inversion. The finished material still contains water; it is not pure, dry fat.
In a 2024 laboratory study, Sandra Beyer Gregersen and colleagues separated buttermilk between two mixing stages. Microscopy and magnetic-resonance measurements showed water droplets approaching commercial butter’s size range. Yet their samples remained softer than the commercial comparison: similar droplets did not guarantee identical texture.
Temperature changes the structure
Stine Rønholt and colleagues compared churning at 10°C and 22°C in a 2014 study. The cooler treatment produced a greater proportion of solid fat and smaller water droplets. It also allowed more water to be incorporated during mixing.
But those structural differences did not translate into a significant difference in the small-deformation mechanical measurements used. The result cautions against predicting butter’s behavior from water content alone. Processing changes several interacting features, including the fat crystals and dispersed droplets.
Our buttermilk explainer distinguishes the churned liquid from modern cultured buttermilk.

Leave a Reply