For an echolocating bat, a smooth pond has a distinctive sound signature. Experiments show that this useful recognition system can also mistake a dry, smooth surface for somewhere to drink.

The echo of a flat surface
Sound striking smooth water obliquely reflects mainly away from the bat, while sound directed straight downward can return. This combination differs from the scattered echoes of a rough surface.
In 2010 laboratory experiments, bats from 15 species attempted to drink from smooth plates, but not textured ones. The main comparison used four species, with smaller tests extending the sample. Five of six young Geoffroy’s bats that had never encountered a pond also tried the smooth plate. That supports an innate component, not a claim that every bat ignores other senses.
Does the illusion survive outdoors?
A 2012 field study covered selected troughs or trough sections with smooth plastic. Bats from 11 species attempted to drink from it, even though real water remained accessible nearby. The false surface elicited repeated attempts rather than just exploratory flyovers.
For barbastelle bats, the researchers also compared recorded calls during approaches to water and plastic. Similar drinking sequences supported their interpretation of the behavior. This was evidence about recognizing a surface under particular conditions, not proof that bats cannot learn or that vision never matters. Please do not reproduce these experiments around wild bats.

A benefit for finding prey
The same reflective setting can help hunting. A 2005 experiment with three pond bats compared detection of prey on smooth surfaces with airborne prey. Changes in calls and three-dimensional video measurements indicated detection at greater distances over the smooth background.
A smooth surface can improve prey detection yet mislead drinking behavior. These are different consequences of interpreting echoes, not contradictory abilities.
Our overview of bat echolocation and other senses explains the broader sensory context.

Leave a Reply