How Do Barnacles Adjust Their Feeding Fans to Moving Water?

By

·

A barnacle’s feathery fan is a set of feeding appendages called cirri. Extended into moving seawater, it gathers suspended food. But a bigger fan is not always better: a structure that intercepts particles must also withstand the water pushing past it.

A giant barnacle underwater with long, feathery cirri extending from its opening.
A giant barnacle, Austromegabalanus psittacus, with its feeding fan extended. This is not one of the species tested below. Photo: Erasmo Macaya, CC BY 4.0; resized.

A fan that changes with its surroundings

In Kerry Marchinko’s 2003 transplant experiments, acorn barnacles from exposed and protected shores were moved into different flow conditions. Both source populations could develop longer cirri in gentler flow. The differences were therefore not simply permanent labels inherited by two separate populations, although the results left room for some genetic contribution.

Adults could change too. In one experiment, wave-exposed Balanus glandula moved into quiet water altered their feeding legs within 18 days, likely spanning one or two molts. This was remodeling over days, not an animal stretching its legs longer each time a wave passed.

Why stronger waves do not mean endlessly shorter legs

A 2004 study by Natasha Li and Mark Denny measured Balanus glandula at 15 Monterey sites spanning water speeds of 0.5 to 14 meters per second. The relationship between faster flow and shorter legs did not continue across that entire range.

The four sites below 3 meters per second showed the familiar change in leg length. Across the 11 faster-flow sites, the researchers found no further corresponding response despite a roughly fourfold speed range. A trend observed in sheltered water could not simply be extrapolated to the roughest shore. These were comparisons among sites, not a demonstration that an individual leg instantly stops changing at one universal threshold.

Small barnacles clustered on a dark submerged surface, with a feathery fan visible near the center.
Feeding barnacles at Yaquina Head, Oregon, not the Monterey experimental animals. Photo: Tara Silber / Bureau of Land Management Oregon and Washington, CC BY 2.0; resized.

Sometimes the best adjustment is to withdraw

Luke Miller’s 2007 field study added a behavioral explanation. A camera watched seven Chthamalus fissus from underneath transparent settlement plates while nearby equipment recorded wave forces. The animals withdrew more often as wave-impact speeds increased, avoiding nearly every sampled impact above about 4–5 meters per second.

Between forceful surges, they could resume feeding. That gives a barnacle another option besides continually shortening its fan: hide it during the brief worst conditions, then use it when the water eases. The author proposed that this behavior helps explain the apparent limit to shape changes; the observations did not prove that every barnacle species uses identical thresholds.

The two responses work on different clocks: remodeling across molts and withdrawal during individual surges. For another shoreline solution, see how mussels anchor themselves with flexible threads.

Response

  1. […] Attachment is separate from how barnacles adjust their feeding fans. […]

Add comment

Leave a Reply